Attachment A
Preliminary Ranking Order of ACE Applications for Year 2005-06
(15 points are needed to qualify for ACE Funding)
Huckleberry Hill Farm, TM 19, Parcel 1 (239.085 acres) 32.86 yes
LLC (Earlysville) TM 19, Parcel 1C ( 6.530 acres)
TM 19, Parcel 4 ( 18.910 acres)
Total (264.525 acres)
Fields, Sally E. TM 81, Parcel 48 (110.810 acres) 24.50 no
(Cismont)
Hook, Jessie T. TM 84, Parcel 11B (120.130 acres) 24.36 no
(Batesville)
Chester, Donal G. TM 65, Parcel 11 ( 22.011 acres) 22.83 yes
(Cismont) TM 65, Parcel 11B ( 2.450 acres)
TM 65, Parcel 11C ( 52.000 acres)
Total ( 76.461 acres)
Motley, Hugh C. TM 66, Parcel 3 ( 36.600 acres) 18.84 yes
(Cismont)
Given, Paul & Julia TM 97, Parcel 19 (125.000 acres) 21.37+ yes *incomplete*
(Batesville)
McLaughlin, Daniel TM 3, Parcel 11 ( 81.498 acres) 13.93 no *ineligible*
(Boonesville)
_____________________________________________________________________
Seven (7) Applicants 815.024 acres
Note: Travel/tourism
value is determined by the presence of specific elements from the ranking
evaluation criteria making
certain properties eligible for funding from the transient lodging tax. The
specific criteria include the following: contains
historic resources or lies in a historic district; lies in the primary
Monticello viewshed; adjoins a Virginia scenic highway,
byway or entrance corridor; lies on a state scenic river; provides mountaintop
protection.
Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination
Owner: Huckleberry Hil Farm , LLC Usable Division Rights
Property: TM 19, Parcel 1(A ) (196.050 acres) 5 DevR's + 8 21's = 13 DivR's
TM 19, Parcel 1(B) ( 17.750 acres) 5 DevR's + 0 21's = 5 DivR's
TM 19, Parcel 1(C) ( 25.330 acres) 2 DevR's + 1 21's = 3 DivR's
TM 19, Parcel 1C ( 6.530 acres) 2 DevR's + 0 21's = 2 DivR's
TM 19, Parcel 4 ( 18.910 acres) 1 DevR's + 0 21's = 1 DivR's
Total (264.570 acres) 15 DevR's + 9 21's = 24 DivR's
Ranking Criteria Determination Source for Points Points
Criteria A.1 no plats/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria A.2 264.570 acres RE Assessor’s Office 5.29
Criteria B.1 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.2 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.3 16 DivR’s eliminated Zoning & Planning Departments 8.00
Criteria C.1 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.2 yes (horses, farming) landowner 5.00
Criteria C.3 450 feet on SR 663 County tax map/plats 2.45
Criteria C.4 yes (buildings) PEC/Monticello viewshed maps 3.00
Criteria C.5 yes DCR Division of Natural Heritage 3.00
Criteria C.6 156 acres County Soil Survey 3.12
Criteria C.7 SF Rivanna River Watershed County overlay maps 3.00
Criteria C.8 no plat/survey/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.9 no landowner 0.00
Criteria C.10 n/a County Engineering Department 0.00
Criteria C.11 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria D.1 info not available VOF, PEC, TNC etc.. ???
Point Total 32.86 points
DevR's = Development Right Lots (2-acre lots); 21's = 21-acre lots; DivR's = Division right lots (2-acre lots + 21 acre lots)
PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council; VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation; TNC =
The Nature Conservancy;
DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation
SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road; CE = Conservation Easement
SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed
SWMHD = Southwest Mountains Rural Historic District
Owner: Fields, Sally E. Usable Division Rights
Property: TM 81, Parcel 48A (<10.000 acres) <2 DevR's + 0 21’s = 2 DivR’s
TM 81, Parcel 48B (>10.000 acres) 4 DevR's + 0 21’s = 4 DivR’s
TM 81, Parcel 48C ( 50.000 acres) 5 DevR's + 1 21’s = 6 DivR’s
TM 81, Parcel 48D (>25.000 acres) 0 DevR's + 0 21’s = 0 DivR’s
Total (110.810 acres) <11 DevR's + 1 21’s = 12 DivR’s
Ranking Criteria Determination Source for Points Points
Criteria A.1 1,900 feet on McCarroll plats/County overlay maps 10.21
922 feet on Skinner
1,282 feet on Airslie
Criteria A.2 110.810 acres RE Assessor’s Office 2.23
Criteria B.1 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.2 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.3 9 DivR’s eliminated Zoning & Planning Departments 4.50
Criteria C.1 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.2 yes (farming) landowner 3.00
Criteria C.3 1,200 feet on SR 600 County tax map/plats 3.20
Criteria C.4 no PEC/Monticello viewshed maps 0.00
Criteria C.5 no DCR Division of Natural Heritage 0.00
Criteria C.6 68 acres County Soil Survey 1.36
Criteria C.7 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.8 no plat/survey/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.9 no landowner 0.00
Criteria C.10 n/a County Engineering Department 0.00
Criteria C.11 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria D.1 info not available VOF, PEC, TNC etc.. ???
Point Total 24.50 points
DevR's = Development Right Lots (2-acre lots); 21's = 21-acre lots; DivR's = Division right lots (2-acre lots + 21 acre lots)
PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council; VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation; TNC =
The Nature Conservancy;
DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation
SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road; CE = Conservation Easement
SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed
SWMHD = Southwest Mountains Rural Historic District
Owner: Hook, Jessie T. Usable Division Rights
Property: TM 84, Parcel 11B “A”
(114.000 acres) 4 DevR’s + 4 21’s = 8 DivR's
TM 84, Parcel 11B “B”
( 7.000 acres) 3 DevR’s + 0 21’s = 3 DivR's
Total (121.040 acres) 7 DevR’s + 4 21’s = 11 DivR's
Ranking Criteria Determination Source for Points Points
Criteria A.1 180 feet on Brane plats/County overlay maps 2.36
Criteria A.2 121.000 acres RE Assessor’s Office 2.40
Criteria B.1 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.2 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.3 9 DivR's eliminated Zoning & Planning Departments 4.50
Criteria C.1 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.2 yes (forest management) landowner 3.00
Criteria C.3 1,200 feet on SR 636 County tax map/plats 3.20
Criteria C.4 no PEC/Monticello viewshed maps 0.00
Criteria C.5 no DCR Division of Natural Heritage 0.00
Criteria C.6 70 acres County Soil Survey 1.40
Criteria C.7 yes (Mechums River) County overlay maps 3.90
Criteria C.8 no plat/survey/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.9 3,600 feet on a perennial stream landowner 3.60
Criteria C.10 n/a County Engineering Department 0.00
Criteria C.11 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria D.1 info not available VOF, PEC, TNC etc.. ???
Point Total 24.36 points
DevR's = Development Right Lots (2-acre lots); 21's = 21-acre lots; DivR's = Division right lots (2-acre lots + 21 acre lots)
PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council; VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation; TNC =
The Nature Conservancy;
DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation
SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road; CE = Conservation Easement
SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed
SWMHD = Southwest Mountains Rural Historic District
Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination
Owner: Chester, Donal G. Usable Division Rights
Property: TM 65, Parcel 11 ( 22.011 acres) 5 DevR’s + 0 21's = 5 DivR's
TM 65, Parcel 11B
( 2.450 acres) 1 DevR’s + 0 21's = 1 DivR's
TM 65, Parcel 11C ( 52.000 acres)
5 DevR's + 2 21's = 7 DivR’s
Total ( 76.461 acres) 11 DevR's + 2 21’s = 13 DivR’s
Ranking Criteria Determination Source for Points Points
Criteria A.1 1,800 feet on Hitchcock plats/County overlay maps 5.60
Criteria A.2 76.461 acres RE Assessor’s Office 1.53
Criteria B.1 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.2 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.3 10 DivR’s eliminated Zoning & Planning Departments 5.00
Criteria C.1 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.2 yes (forest management) landowner 3.00
Criteria C.3 1,800 feet on SR 600 County tax map/plats 3.80
Criteria C.4 yes (SWMHD) PEC/Monticello viewshed maps 3.00
Criteria C.5 no DCR Division of Natural Heritage 0.00
Criteria C.6 45 acres County Soil Survey 0.90
Criteria C.7 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.8 no plat/survey/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.9 owner not interested landowner 0.00
Criteria C.10 n/a County Engineering Department 0.00
Criteria C.11 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria D.1 info not available VOF, PEC, TNC etc.. ???
Point Total 22.83 points
DevR's = Development Right Lots (2-acre lots); 21's = 21-acre lots; DivR's = Division right lots (2-acre lots + 21 acre lots)
PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council; VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation; TNC =
The Nature Conservancy;
DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation
SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road; CE = Conservation Easement
SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed
SWMHD = Southwest Mountains Rural Historic District
Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination
Owner: Hugh & Kathleen Motley Usable Division Rights
Property: TM 66 Parcel 3 (36.600 acres) 1 DevR’s + 1 21’s = 2 DivR’s
Ranking Criteria Determination Source for Points Points
Criteria A.1 1,500 feet on Lewis plats/County overlay maps 5.00
Criteria A.2 36.600 acres RE Assessor’s Office 0.73
Criteria B.1 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.2 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.3 1 DivR eliminated Zoning & Planning Departments 0.50
Criteria C.1 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.2 yes (horses) landowner 3.00
Criteria C.3 1,134 feet on SR 231 County tax map/plats 3.89
Criteria C.4 yes (SWMHD) PEC/Monticello viewshed maps 3.00
Criteria C.5 no DCR Division of Natural Heritage 0.00
Criteria C.6 26 acres County Soil Survey 0.52
Criteria C.7 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.8 no plat/survey/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.9 2,200 feet on 2 perennial streams landowner 2.20
Criteria C.10 n/a County Engineering Department 0.00
Criteria C.11 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria D.1 info not available VOF, PEC, TNC etc.. ???
Point Total 18.84 points
DevR's = Development Right Lots (2-acre lots); 21's = 21-acre lots; DivR's = Division right lots (2-acre lots + 21 acre lots)
PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council; VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation; TNC =
The Nature Conservancy;
DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation
SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road; CE = Conservation Easement
SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed
SWMHD = Southwest Mountains Rural Historic District
Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination ** Incomplete Application **
Owner: Given, Paul & Julia Usable Division Rights
Property: TM 97, Parcel 19 #1 (118.000 acres) 2 DevR’s + 0 21’s = 2 DivR’s TM 97, Parcel 19 #2 ( 40.000 acres) 1 DevR’s + 0 21’s = 1 DivR’s
TM 97, Parcel 19 #3 ( 3.300 acres) 1 DevR’s + 0 21’s = 1 DivR’s
Total (161.300 acres) 4 DevR’s + 0 21’s = 4 DivR’s
Ranking Criteria Determination Source for Points Points
Criteria A.1 2,760 feet on Helms plats/County overlay maps 7.52
Criteria A.2 125.000 acres RE Assessor’s Office 2.40
Criteria B.1 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.2 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.3 2 DivR’s eliminated Zoning & Planning Departments 1.00
Criteria C.1 27 acres on Castle Rock Mtn. County overlay maps 1.35
Criteria C.2 no landowner 0.00
Criteria C.3 right-of-way County tax map/plats 0.00
Criteria C.4 no PEC/Monticello viewshed maps 0.00
Criteria C.5 no DCR Division of Natural Heritage 0.00
Criteria C.6 80 acres County Soil Survey 1.60
Criteria C.7 yes (SFRR) County overlay maps 3.00
Criteria C.8 no plat/survey/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.9 4,500 feet on 2 perennial streams landowner 4.50-9.00
Criteria C.10 n/a County Engineering Department 0.00
Criteria C.11 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria D.1 info not available VOF, PEC, TNC etc.. ???
Point Total 21.37 points
DevR's = Development Right Lots (2-acre lots); 21's = 21-acre lots; DivR's = Division right lots (2-acre lots + 21 acre lots)
PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council; VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation; TNC =
The Nature Conservancy;
DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation
SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road; CE = Conservation Easement
SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed
SWMHD = Southwest Mountains Rural Historic District
Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination ** Ineligible Application **
Owner: McLaughlin, Daniel Usable Division Rights
Property: TM 3, Parcel 11 (81.498 acres) 1 DevR’s + 3 21’s = <4 DivR’s
Ranking Criteria Determination Source for Points Points
Criteria A.1 no plats/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria A.2 81.498 acres RE Assessor’s Office 1.63
Criteria B.1 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.2 no landowner 0.00
Criteria B.3 2 DivR’s eliminated Zoning & Planning Departments 1.00
Criteria C.1 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.2 yes (forest management) landowner 3.00
Criteria C.3 right-of-way County tax map/plats 0.00
Criteria C.4 no PEC/Monticello viewshed maps 0.00
Criteria C.5 no DCR Division of Natural Heritage 0.00
Criteria C.6 25 acres County Soil Survey 0.50
Criteria C.7 yes (SFRR) County overlay maps 3.00
Criteria C.8 no plat/survey/County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria C.9 2,400 feet on a perennial stream landowner 4.80
Criteria C.10 n/a County Engineering Department 0.00
Criteria C.11 no County overlay maps 0.00
Criteria D.1 info not available VOF, PEC, TNC etc.. ???
Point Total 13.93 points (ineligible)
DevR's = Development Right Lots (2-acre lots); 21's = 21-acre lots; DivR's = Division right lots (2-acre lots + 21 acre lots)
PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council; VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation; TNC =
The Nature Conservancy;
DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation
SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road; CE = Conservation Easement
SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed
SWMHD = Southwest Mountains Rural Historic District