Attachment ďAĒ

 

 

Preliminary Ranking Order for Round 4 ACE Applicants - FY  2003-04

(15 points are needed to qualify for ACE Funding)

 

 

Applicant                        Tax Map (Acreage)                                          Points         Travel/Tourism Value*

 

 

Colombini, Carlo           TM  47, Parcel 12A  (  1.000 acres)   37.24     yes

(Stony Point)                        TM  47, Parcel 14   ( 65.500 acres)  

TM  62, Parcel 50F  ( 41.000 acres)

TM  62, Parcel 52   ( 50.398 acres)                

Total               (157.898 acres)

 

Scruby, Brian                   TM  54, Parcel 72A  (  1.100 acres)   27.72     yes

(Greenwood)                         TM  55, Parcel 14   ( 43.510 acres)  

TM  69, Parcel 39A  ( 56.889 acres)                

Total               (101.499 acres)

 

Page, Henry C.           TM  73, Parcel 24   (558.900 acres)   25.13     yes

(North Garden)       

 

Bieker, Daniel            TM  99, Parcel 38A  ( 75.250 acres)   19.57     yes

(North Garden)                     TM  99, Parcel 39   ( 13.190 acres)

                  TM  99, Parcel 40   ( 17.000 acres)

Total               (105.440 acres)

 

Shifflett, James M.     TM   7, Parcel 25   ( 61.600 acres)   19.40     yes

(Boonesville)                       

 

Hill, Samuel        TM 130, Parcel 17B  (145.210 acres)   17.50     yes

(Scottsville)          

 

Scruby, Timothy          TM  54, Parcel 71   ( 11.556 acres)   16.40     yes

(Greenwood)         TM  69, Parcel 39   ( 25.318 acres)

                  TM  70, Parcel 33A  ( 69.381 acres)

                  Total               (106.255 acres)

 

AEF                             TM  85, Parcel 40   (182.400 acres)   13.67     yes  * ineligible *

(Batesville)          

_____________________________________________________________________

Seven (7) Applicants                1,419.202 acres      

 

 

 

Note:  Travel/tourism value is determined by the presence of specific elements from the ranking evaluation criteria making certain properties eligible for funding from the transient lodging tax.  The specific criteria include the following: contains historic resources or lies in a historic district; lies in the primary Monticello viewshed; adjoins a Virginia scenic highway, byway or entrance corridor; lies on a state scenic river; provides mountaintop protection.

Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination

 

 

Owner:            Colombini, Carlo

Property:                TM  47, Parcel 12A              (    1.000 acres)                     0 DRís + 0 DRís = 0 DRís  

                                TM  47, Parcel 14                  (  65.500 acres)                     0 DRís + 0 DRís = 0 DRís

TM  62, Parcel 50F                (  41.000 acres)                     3 DRís + 0 DRís = 3 DRís

TM  62, Parcel 52                  (  50.398 acres)                     5 DRís + 1 DRís = 6 DRís

Total                                       (157.898 acres)                     8 DRís + 1 DRís = 9 DRís

 

Ranking Criteria            Determination                           Source for Points                         Points

Criteria A.1                        >8,000í along existing easements    plats/County overlay maps                        16.20   

               

Criteria A.2                            157.898 acres                                         RE Assessorís Office                               3.16

 

Criteria B.1                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.3                             7 DRís eliminated                                Zoning & Planning Departments         3.50

 

Criteria C.1                             no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

                                               

Criteria C.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria C.3                             459í  on SR 649                                     County tax  map/plats                              0.46

                               

Criteria C.4                             yes - SWMHD                                      PEC/Monticello viewshed maps             3.00

 

Criteria C.5                             ?                                                              DCR Division of Natural Heritage      5.00

 

Criteria C.6                             116 acres                                                County Soil Survey                                 2.32

 

Criteria C.7                             7,200í on NF Rivanna River                County overlay maps                               3.60

               

Criteria C.8                             no                                                           plat/survey/County overlay maps         0.00

 

Criteria C.9                             probably                                               landowner                                                      ?

 

Criteria C.10                           n/a                                                          County Engineering Department            0.00

 

Criteria C.11                           no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria D.1                            maybe                                                    TNC/spiny mussell.                                       ?

Point Total                                                                                                                                                               37.24+points

 

 

PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council

VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation

TNC = The Nature Conservancy

DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation

SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road

CE = Conservation Easement

SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed

SWMHD = Southwest Mountains Historic District

Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination

 

 

Owner:            Scruby, Brian  G.                                                                   

Property:           TM 54, Parcel 72A                (    1.100 acres)                     0 DRís + 0 DRís = 0 DRís  

TM 55, Parcel 14                    (  43.510 acres)                     5 DRís + 0 DRís = 5 DRís

TM 69, Parcel 39A                 (  56.889 acres)                     2 DRís + 2 DRís = 4 DRís

Total                                        (101.499 acres)                     7 DRís + 2 DRís = 9 DRís

 

Ranking Criteria            Determination                           Source for Points                         Points

Criteria A.1                        >3,000í along existing easements    plats/County overlay maps                           6.47   

               

Criteria A.2                            101.499 acres                                         RE Assessorís Office                               2.03

 

Criteria B.1                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.3                             7 DRís eliminated                                 Zoning & Planning Departments           3.50

 

Criteria C.1                             no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

                                               

Criteria C.2                             yes (farming)                                         landowner                                                  5.00

 

Criteria C.3                             2,550í on EC                                          County tax  map/plats                              5.86

1,610í on SR                                         

 

Criteria C.4                             no                                                           PEC/Monticello viewshed maps             0.00

 

Criteria C.5                             no                                                           DCR Division of Natural Heritage          0.00

 

Criteria C.6                             93 acres                                                  County Soil Survey                                  1.86

 

Criteria C.7                             yes - in SFRR watershed                     County overlay maps                               3.00

               

Criteria C.8                             no                                                           plat/survey/County overlay maps         0.00

 

Criteria C.9                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria C.10                           n/a                                                          County Engineering Department            0.00

 

Criteria C.11                           no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria D.1                            no                                                           VOF, PEC, TNC etc.                                  0.00

Point Total                                                                                                                                                               27.72 points

 

 

PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council

VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation

TNC = The Nature Conservancy

DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation

SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road

CE = Conservation Easement

SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed

 

Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination

 

 

Owner:            Page, Henry C.                

Property:           Tax Map 73, Parcel 24          (558.900 acres)                      0 DRís + 5 DRís = 5 DRís

                         

                       

Ranking Criteria            Determination                           Source for Points                         Points

Criteria A.1                            no                                                          PEC/plats                                                    0.00

               

Criteria A.2                            558.900 acres                                         RE Assessorís Office                             11.18

 

Criteria B.1                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.3                             4 DRís eliminated                                 Zoning & Planning Departments          2.00

 

Criteria C.1                            39 acres of mountaintop                      county overlay maps                               1.95

 

Criteria C.2                             yes (farming)                                         landowner                                                  5.00

 

Criteria C.3                             no                                                           County tax  map                                        0.00

 

Criteria C.4                             no                                                           PEC & Monticello viewshed maps         0.00

 

Criteria C.5                             no                                                           DCR Division of Natural Heritage          0.00

 

Criteria C.6                             >250 acres                                             County Soil Survey                                  5.00

 

Criteria C.7                             no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria C.8                             no                                                           plats/surveys, County overlay maps                     0.00

 

Criteria C.9                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria C.10                           n/a                                                          County Engineering Department            0.00

 

Criteria C.11                           no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria D.1                            no                                                           VOF, PEC, TNC etc.                                  0.00

Point Total                                                                                                                                                             25.13 points

 

 

PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council.

VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation.

TNC = The Nature Conservancy

DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation

SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road

SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed

 

 

 

 

 

Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination

 

 

Owner:            Bieker, Daniel  J.            

Property:           Tax Map 99, Parcel 38A      (  75.250 acres)                      5 DRís + 3 DRís = 8 DRís

                                Tax Map 99, Parcel 39          (  13.190 acres)                      0 DRís + 0 DRís = 0 DRís

                                Tax Map 99, Parcel 40          (  17.000 acres)                      0 DRís + 0 DRís = 0 DRís

Total                                       (105.440 acres)                      5 DRís + 3 DRís = 8 DRís

 

 

Ranking Criteria            Determination                           Source for Points                         Points

Criteria A.1                            no                                                           PEC/plats                                                    0.00   

               

Criteria A.2                            105.440 acres                                         RE Assessorís Office                              2.11

 

Criteria B.1                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.3                             7 DRís eliminated                                 Zoning & Planning Departments          3.50

 

Criteria C.1                             21 acres of mountaintop                    county overlay maps                                1.04                   

Criteria C.2                             yes (farming)                                         landowner                                                  3.00

 

Criteria C.3                             no                                                           County tax  map                                        0.00

 

Criteria C.4                             no                                                           PEC & Monticello viewshed maps         0.00

 

Criteria C.5                             no                                                           DCR Division of Natural Heritage          0.00

 

Criteria C.6                             66 acres  of mountaintop                     County Soil Survey                                  1.32

 

Criteria C.7                             no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

               

Criteria C.8                             no                                                           plats/surveys, County overlay maps                     0.00

 

Criteria C.9                             4,300 feet (>100í wide)                         landowner                                                  8.60

 

Criteria C.10                           n/a                                                          County Engineering Department            0.00

 

Criteria C.11                           no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria D.1                            no                                                           VOF, PEC, TNC etc.                                 0.00

Point Total                                                                                                                                                             19.57 points

 

 

PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council.

VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation.

TNC = The Nature Conservancy

DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation

SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road

SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed

 

 

 

 

Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination

 

 

Owner:            Shifflett, James M. & Mary H.               

Property:           Tax Map 7, Parcel 25            (61.600 acres)        5 DRís 2 DRís = 7 DRís

                         

                       

Ranking Criteria            Determination                           Source for Points                         Points

Criteria A.1                            >1,695í along existing easements      PEC/plats                                                    3.39

               

Criteria A.2                            61.600 acres                                           RE Assessorís Office                               1.23

 

Criteria B.1                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.2                             yes                                                          landowner                                                  3.00

 

Criteria B.3                             6 DRís eliminated                                 Zoning & Planning Departments          3.00

 

Criteria C.1                            16 acres of mountaintop                      county overlay map                                  0.80             

Criteria C.2                             yes (forestry)                                        landowner                                                  3.00

 

Criteria C.3                             1,200í on SR                                          County tax  map                                        1.20

 

Criteria C.4                             no                                                           PEC & Monticello viewshed maps         0.00

 

Criteria C.5                             no                                                           DCR Division of Natural Heritage          0.00

 

Criteria C.6                             39 acres                                                  County Soil Survey                                  0.78

 

Criteria C.7                             yes - in SFRR watershed                     County overlay maps                               3.00

               

Criteria C.8                             no                                                           plats/surveys, County overlay maps      0.00

 

Criteria C.9                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria C.10                           n/a                                                          County Engineering Department            0.00

 

Criteria C.11                           no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria D.1                            no                                                           VOF, PEC, TNC etc.                                  0.00

Point Total                                                                                                                                                              19.40 points

 

 

PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council.

VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation.

TNC = The Nature Conservancy

DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation

SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road

SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed

 

 

 

 

 

Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination

 

 

Owner:            Hill, Samuel        

Property:           Tax Map 130, Parcel 17B     (145.210 acres)     5 DRís + 6 DRís = 11 DRís 

             

                       

Ranking Criteria            Determination                           Source for Points                         Points

Criteria A.1                            no                                                           PEC/plats                                                    0.00   

               

Criteria A.2                            145.210 acres                                         RE Assessorís Office                               2.90

 

Criteria B.1                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.3                             9 DRís eliminated                                 Zoning & Planning Departments          4.50

 

Criteria C.1                             no                                                            county overlay maps                               0.00                  

Criteria C.2                             yes (farming)                                         landowner                                                  3.00

 

Criteria C.3                             1,800í on SH/EC                                   County tax  map                                        3.00

 

Criteria C.4                             no                                                           PEC & Monticello viewshed maps         0.00

 

Criteria C.5                             no                                                           DCR Division of Natural Heritage          0.00

 

Criteria C.6                             55 acres                                                  County Soil Survey                                  1.10

 

Criteria C.7                             yes - in TC watershed                         County overlay maps                               3.00

               

Criteria C.8                             no                                                           plats/surveys, County overlay maps                     0.00

 

Criteria C.9                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria C.10                           n/a                                                          County Engineering Department            0.00

 

Criteria C.11                           no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria D.1                            no                                                           VOF, PEC, TNC etc.                                 0.00

Point Total                                                                                                                                                              17.50 points

 

 

PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council.

VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation.

TNC = The Nature Conservancy

DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation

SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road

SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed; TC = Totier Creek watershed

 

 

 

 

Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination

 

 

Owner:             Scruby, Tim & Alice

Property:           Tax Map 54, Parcel 71          (  25.318 acres)                        5 DRís + 0 DRís =   5 DRís 

                                Tax Map 69, Parcel 39           (  69.381 acres)                        5 DRís + 0 DRís =   5 DRís

                                Tax Map 70, Parcel 33A        (  11.556 acres)                        0 DRís + 3 DRís =   3 DRís

Total                                        (106.255 acres)                      10 DRís + 3 DRís = 13 DRís

 

 

Ranking Criteria            Determination                           Source for Points                         Points

Criteria A.1                            no                                                           PEC/plats                                                    0.00   

               

Criteria A.2                            106.255 acres                                         RE Assessorís Office                               2.13

 

Criteria B.1                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.3                             11 DRís eliminated                               Zoning & Planning Departments           5.50

 

Criteria C.1                             no                                                          county overlay maps                                 0.00                  

Criteria C.2                             yes                                                          landowner                                                  3.00

 

Criteria C.3                             1,757 on EC                                           County tax  map/plats                              1.76

                                               

Criteria C.4                             no                                                           PEC & Monticello viewshed maps         0.00

 

Criteria C.5                             no                                                           DCR Division of Natural Heritage          0.00

 

Criteria C.6                             101 acres                                                County Soil Survey                                  2.01

 

Criteria C.7                             yes                                                          County overlay maps                               3.00

               

Criteria C.8                             no                                                           plats/surveys, County overlay maps                     0.00

 

Criteria C.9                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria C.10                           n/a                                                          County Engineering Department            0.00

 

Criteria C.11                           no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria D.1                            no                                                           VOF, PEC, TNC etc.                                  0.00

Point Total                                                                                                                                                             17.40 points

 

 

PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council.

VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation.

TNC = The Nature Conservancy

DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation

SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road

SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed

 

 

 

Ranking Evaluation Criteria & Points Determination

 

 

Owner:            American Environmental Foundation (AEF)                  

Property:           Tax Map 85,, Parcel 40         (182.40 acres)          0 DRís + 8 DRís = 8 DRsís

                         

                       

Ranking Criteria            Determination                           Source for Points                         Points

Criteria A.1                            no                                                           PEC/plats                                                    0.00   

               

Criteria A.2                            182.400 acres                                         RE Assessorís Office                               3.65

 

Criteria B.1                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria B.3                             7 DRís eliminated                                Zoning & Planning Departments          3.50

 

Criteria C.1                        28 acres of mountaintop                         county overlay maps                                1.40                  

Criteria C.2                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria C.3                             no                                                           County tax  map                                        0.00

 

Criteria C.4                             no                                                           PEC & Monticello viewshed maps         0.00

 

Criteria C.5                             no                                                           DCR Division of Natural Heritage          0.00

 

Criteria C.6                             81 acres                                                  County Soil Survey                                 1.62

 

Criteria C.7                             yes - in SFRR watershed                     County overlay maps                               3.00

               

Criteria C.8                             no                                                           plats/surveys, County overlay maps                     0.00

 

Criteria C.9                             no                                                           landowner                                                  0.00

 

Criteria C.10                           n/a                                                          County Engineering Department            0.00

 

Criteria C.11                           no                                                           County overlay maps                               0.00

 

Criteria D.1                            no                                                           VOF, PEC, TNC etc.                                 0.00

Point Total                                                                                                                                                               13.17 points

 

 

PEC = Piedmont Environmental Council.

VOF = Virginia Outdoors Foundation.

TNC = The Nature Conservancy

DCR = Department of Conservation and Recreation

SH = Scenic Highway; EC = entrance corridor; SR = State Road

SFRR = South Fork Rivanna River watershed; TC = Totier Creek watershed

 

Go to Attachment B

Return to executive summary